With the recent influx of mostly young, male migrants into Germany, their violent crime rate has also gone up in the country found a study published on Wednesday, reports the Associated Press.
The study used figures from the northern state of Lower Saxony to examine the impact of refugee arrivals on crime in 2015 and 2016, a period when the number of violent crimes reported increased by 10.4 percent.
The authors concluded that 92 percent of the additional crimes recorded could be attributed to the increase in refugee numbers. The study also noted that the demographic composition of the refugee population is a major factor. Young males are more likely to commit crimes in general, whether they are German or night, but are also most likely to be the victims as well.
These findings complicate the ongoing debate Germany and a lot of European countries are having on how to tackle migrant crime, which has been fanned by a number of high-profile incidents.
Parties on the right, including German Chancellor Angela Merkel’s Union bloc, want a tough response and more deportations while those on the left say more needs to be done to integrate migrants into German society.
“It is true that since 2015 there has been a rise in violent crime that the authors attribute to the arrival of refugees,” said Verena Herb, a spokeswoman for the Families Ministry that commissioned the study. “But they also make very clear that refugees aren’t generally more criminal than for example Germans.”
Herb continued saying that the biggest problems with these incidents of crime is that these young men see very little hope for their futures. Migrants from North Africa were found to be more likely to commit a crime than Afghans and Syrians because North Africans have a very little chance of being granted permission to stay in Germany.
“In our view, this shows once more that those who come here mustn’t be left to their own devices,” she said. “Only that way can we ensure that boredom and frustration don’t result in criminal behavior.”
The study, led by prominent criminologist Christian Pfeiffer and published by the Zurich University of Applied Sciences, says most of the refugees came to Germany from Muslim countries that are “characterized by male dominance” and an acceptance of a “macho culture” that can justify violence.
The lack of women in these refugee populations also seems to be an upsetting factor and a contributing factor to the criminality.
“This makes it more likely for groups of young men to emerge among the refugees and they can develop a violent dynamic of their own,” the authors wrote, concluding that it makes sense to allow refugees to bring over their families.
The report also notes that people are twice as likely to report crimes if they are committed by people who are different from them, causing some distortion in the crime statistics.